Sherlock Holmes Inn, Melbourne, Victoria

Recent reviews

• Date of review 04 Jan 2012
  Rated by #20258 - Milney (4 reviews)
  Rating 67%
  Price Not specified
  Type of meat chicken
  Size of chicken parmigiana 4 / 5 (very good)
  Quality of meat 4 / 5 (very good)
  Quality of topping 2 / 5 (ok)
  Quality of chips 3 / 5 (good)
  Quantity of chips 2.5 / 3 (very good)
  Salad/Vegie rating 2 / 3 (good)
  Bonus points N/A
  Was this a special? No
  

  Milney reckons:

  Great size for a chicken parma, chips were great. Sauce was well seasoned, but lacking in volume.

• Date of review 19 Sep 2011
  Rated by #7458 - daz07 (5 reviews)
  Rating 79%
  Price $21.00
  Type of meat chicken
  Size of chicken parmigiana 4 / 5 (very good)
  Quality of meat 5 / 5 (excellent)
  Quality of topping 4 / 5 (very good)
  Quality of chips 3 / 5 (good)
  Quantity of chips 2.5 / 3 (very good)
  Salad/Vegie rating 2 / 3 (good)
  Bonus points N/A
  Was this a special? No
  

  daz07 reckons:

  Really nice quality parma, great piece of chicken. It was deep fried which I know a lot of you don't like, but when they use the technique to give you a crunchy crumb while keeping the chicken juicy and tender then I'm all for it! A great all round meal with decent chips and salad, although the parma was served on top of the chips unfortunately. I will definitely be returning for this one.

  Bronze reviewer
• Date of review 23 Oct 2008
  Rated by #2370 - Jazz (1 review)
  Rating 87%
  Price $16.00
  Type of meat chicken
  Size of chicken parmigiana 5 / 5 (excellent)
  Quality of meat 5 / 5 (excellent)
  Quality of topping 5 / 5 (excellent)
  Quality of chips 2 / 5 (ok)
  Quantity of chips 2.5 / 3 (very good)
  Salad/Vegie rating Not rated
  Bonus points +1
  Was this a special? Yes
  

  Jazz reckons:

  Bonus point for very fast service (6 of us ordered parmas - arrived within minutes). $16 was Wednesday night deal including a pint of beer.

  Special
• Date of review 27 Jun 2008
  Rated by #257 - Mark (15 reviews)
  Rating 77%
  Price $18.00
  Type of meat chicken
  Size of chicken parmigiana 4 / 5 (very good)
  Quality of meat 4 / 5 (very good)
  Quality of topping 5 / 5 (excellent)
  Quality of chips 3 / 5 (good)
  Quantity of chips 2.5 / 3 (very good)
  Salad/Vegie rating 2.5 / 3 (very good)
  Bonus points -1
  Was this a special? No
  

  Mark reckons:

  The meal itself was really nice but the kitchen was unorganised, received meal some time after Brad had finished and left.

  Silver reviewer
• Date of review 27 Jun 2008
  Rated by #33 - Brad (126 reviews)
  Rating 81%
  Price $18.00
  Type of meat chicken
  Size of chicken parmigiana 4 / 5 (very good)
  Quality of meat 5 / 5 (excellent)
  Quality of topping 5 / 5 (excellent)
  Quality of chips 2 / 5 (ok)
  Quantity of chips 2 / 3 (good)
  Salad/Vegie rating Not rated
  Bonus points +1
  Was this a special? No
  

  Brad reckons:

  Bonus point for the choice of toppings and the vegetables option. The chips were a disappointment.

  Official reviewer
• Date of review 22 May 2008
  Rated by #737 - Tim (2 reviews)
  Rating 76%
  Price $17.00
  Type of meat chicken
  Size of chicken parmigiana 4 / 5 (very good)
  Quality of meat 4 / 5 (very good)
  Quality of topping 4 / 5 (very good)
  Quality of chips 3 / 5 (good)
  Quantity of chips 2.5 / 3 (very good)
  Salad/Vegie rating Not rated
  Bonus points N/A
  Was this a special? No