Rating Criteria

To ensure consistent reviews from different people around the country, we have developed a set of parmigiana rating criteria. The weighting of the rating criteria varies depending on the importance of the criteria. A bonus point can also be awarded or subtracted if the person rating the parmigiana feels it is warranted. In this instance, a comment must be included explaining why the bonus point was given or subtracted from the rating.

Parmigiana size
Out of 5, this criteria indicates the size of the parmigiana.
  • 0 points (very poor)
  • 1 point (poor)
  • 2 points (ok)
  • 3 points (good)
  • 4 points (very good)
  • 5 points (excellent)
Quality of meat
Out of 5, this criteria indicates the quality of the chicken breast (or whatever the type of meat may be).
  • 0 points (very poor)
  • 1 point (poor)
  • 2 points (ok)
  • 3 points (good)
  • 4 points (very good)
  • 5 points (excellent)
Quality of topping
Out of 5, this criteria indicates the quality of the parmigiana topping, the main flavour source in the parmigiana package.
  • 0 points (very poor)
  • 1 point (poor)
  • 2 points (ok)
  • 3 points (good)
  • 4 points (very good)
  • 5 points (excellent)
Quality of chips
Out of 5, this criteria indicates the quality of the chips. While technically only a side dish, the side of chips has developed into as much of a tradition as the parmigiana itself and is standard on most plates served.
  • 0 points (very poor)
  • 1 point (poor)
  • 2 points (ok)
  • 3 points (good)
  • 4 points (very good)
  • 5 points (excellent)
Quantity of chips
Out of 3, this criteria indicates the quantity of chips served.
  • 0 points (very poor)
  • 1 point (poor)
  • 1.5 points (ok)
  • 2 points (good)
  • 2.5 points (very good)
  • 3 points (excellent)
Salad/vegie rating
Out of 3, this criteria indicates quality of the accompanying serve of salad or vegetables.
  • 0 points (very poor)
  • 1 point (poor)
  • 1.5 points (ok)
  • 2 points (good)
  • 2.5 points (very good)
  • 3 points (excellent)
Bonus points
A bonus point can also be awarded or subtracted if the person rating the parmigiana feels it is warranted. In this instance, a comment must be included explaining why the bonus point was given or subtracted from the rating.
  • +1 point
  • -1 point