Pugg Mahones

175 Elgin Street, Carlton 3035 · VIC · Pub

80 %

IQM rating

Log in to submit a review.

Reviews (18)

mnwlkr

19 Jun 2012

52%

"chicken"

Thought this was a bit bland and lacked a strong flavour. Amount of chips was just enough. The thickness of the chicken was average and a little dry. Dont think I would go there again.

Size
3/5
Meat
2/5
Topping
2/5
Chips Quality
3/5
Chips Qty
1.5/3
Salad
2/3

Chad Baygon

5 May 2012 · $17.50

77%

"chicken"

Pretty solid Parma down at Puggs, the breast was quality and a nice size (although I generally prefer them fractionally thicker), cheese was nicely melted however sauce was only ok (I suspect it was your typical sauce from a jar here). The addition of ham was as usual welcomed with open arms and the chips were better than average, unfortunately their lack of abundance lost them points here. Chips were placed under the Parma however this doesn't tend to phase me as long as they retain their integrity, in this case they were still crisp and tasty. Salad was the usual stock standard and did the job in complementing the meal. Overall as Mentioned earlier a pretty solid Parma and washed down with a few cold beers whilst watching the footy capped off a great lunch! Would recommend.

Size
4/5
Meat
4/5
Topping
4/5
Chips Quality
4/5
Chips Qty
1.5/3
Salad
2/3

Russ

2 Jul 2010 · $12.50 (on special)

92%

"chicken"

Good sized portions of parma, chips and salad makes for a great meal that tastes good as a whole and is very filling. Even the 'classier' version served for dinner and on weekends is just as delicious

Size
4/5
Meat
5/5
Topping
5/5
Chips Quality
4/5
Chips Qty
2.5/3
Salad
3/3

Maudey

30 Jun 2010 · $12.50 (on special)

87%

"chicken"

Perfect heat, cut amazingly, went downa treat.

Size
4/5
Meat
4/5
Topping
5/5
Chips Quality
4/5
Chips Qty
2.5/3

Camt

30 Jun 2010 · $12.50 (on special)

100%

"chicken"

Perfection on a plate :-)

Size
5/5
Meat
5/5
Topping
5/5
Chips Quality
5/5
Chips Qty
3/3
Salad
3/3

Tad Moore

30 Jun 2010 · $12.50 (on special)

83%

"chicken"

Delicious parma and at $12.50 you can't go wrong. Packed with college students and old timers great atmosphere. -1 bonus point however goes to the tall strawberry blonde bloke wearing ripped jeans and a stripey v neck t-shirt. SERIOUSLY mate its an irish pub not a friggen fashion show. p.s. you looked ridiculous.

Size
4/5
Meat
5/5
Topping
4/5
Chips Quality
5/5
Chips Qty
3/3
Salad
1.5/3

Michael

30 Jun 2010 · $12.50 (on special)

96%

"chicken"

fast service and good quality salad

Size
5/5
Meat
4/5
Topping
5/5
Chips Quality
5/5
Chips Qty
3/3
Salad
2.5/3

Samantha Roder

29 Jun 2010 · $12.50 (on special)

96%

"chicken"

I get free food at college, but i choose to spend my money at Pugg's koz the parma's are brilliant!!!

Size
5/5
Meat
5/5
Topping
5/5
Chips Quality
5/5
Chips Qty
3/3
Salad
2/3

Wristwatch

29 Jun 2010 · $12.50 (on special)

98%

"chicken"

Great atmosphere, great staff!! Special shout out to the guy who looks like Edward Cullen on a Wednesday night, if you are reading this give me a call!! Also you should probably lose your mate, the one with the receding hairline... he is runing your street cred!!

Size
5/5
Meat
4/5
Topping
5/5
Chips Quality
5/5
Chips Qty
3/3
Salad
3/3

David Mulholland

29 Jun 2010 · $12.50 (on special)

100%

"chicken"

The thursday Parmas at puggs are awesome, highly reccommended

Size
5/5
Meat
5/5
Topping
5/5
Chips Quality
5/5
Chips Qty
3/3
Salad
2.5/3

Jamie

29 Jun 2010 · $12.50 (on special)

98%

"chicken"

Puggs is an institution that is not normally known for its meals. This will soon change when word spreads. After demolishing a parma last week I was left to ask what more could I want? They delivered high quality service, great beer and a bloody fantastic parma!!!

Size
5/5
Meat
5/5
Topping
5/5
Chips Quality
5/5
Chips Qty
3/3
Salad
2/3

Jake

29 Jun 2010

98%

"chicken"

Puugs is not only about the parma but also the homeliness and culture of the place.

Size
4/5
Meat
5/5
Topping
5/5
Chips Quality
5/5
Chips Qty
3/3
Salad
3/3

doggy style

29 Jun 2010 · $12.50 (on special)

91%

"chicken"

Delish, and the best service in this part of Melbourne

Size
5/5
Meat
4/5
Topping
4/5
Chips Quality
5/5
Chips Qty
2/3
Salad
3/3

Jenkins

29 Jun 2010

81%

"chicken"

Great venue, especially if you live at college. Because you end up living at Puggs too.

Size
5/5
Meat
4/5
Topping
4/5
Chips Quality
4/5
Chips Qty
2/3
Salad
2/3

Rambo

29 Jun 2010 · $12.50 (on special)

87%

"chicken"

all good...huuuge portion, almost left some on the plate but it was too delicous

Size
5/5
Meat
4/5
Topping
4/5
Chips Quality
4/5
Chips Qty
3/3
Salad
2/3

Xavier

29 Jun 2010

98%

"chicken"

Friendly staff and a great atmosphere make this delicious Parma an absolute must if you're in the Carlton area and like all good university students, after a day at Melb Uni, I enjoy a good Parma.

Size
5/5
Meat
5/5
Topping
5/5
Chips Quality
5/5
Chips Qty
2.5/3
Salad
2.5/3

Spam

1 Jun 2009 · $17.00

75%

"chicken"

Pretty happy with that parma overall but not excited about the salad... but who cares about the salad right?

Size
4/5
Meat
3/5
Topping
4/5
Chips Quality
4/5
Chips Qty
3/3
Salad
1.5/3

Brad Official

31 May 2009 · $17.00

78%

"chicken"

Packed full with some of Carlton's finest; it's certainly not what you'd call a family venue. Despite the chants from the local college youths, they serve up a pretty decent parma. The full points for quantity of chips was well deserved.

Size
4/5
Meat
4/5
Topping
4/5
Chips Quality
3/5
Chips Qty
3/3